Benefit They're Real & Roller Lash Mascaras

14/7/2021

59 Comments

Here is my Comparison and Review for Benefit's Best Selling Mascaras

They're Real!

What is it?

They're Real:

Lengthens
Curls
Volumises
Lifts and Separates.

This jet black, long-wearing formula won't smudge or dry out and comes with a specially designed brush which reveals lashes you never knew you had!

If you’ve been dreaming of long, fluttery lashes, it’s time for Benefit to make your dreams a reality. Benefit They’re Real mascara visibly lengthens and curls eyelashes, adding impressive volume and drama

Key Mentions:

Long Wearing Formula
Jet Black Colour
Water-Resistant
Adds Visible Drama
UK's number one best selling Prestige Mascara
Dome-Tipped Brush

The Wand

They're Real comes with a Dome-Tipped Brush that visibly Lengthens and curls eyelashes, adding impressive volume and drama. This also makes it easier to coat otherwise hard to reach corner lashes.

How to Apply?

1. Hold the mascara wand horizontally and move it from side to side to coat lashes in the product.

2. Next, move the brush from the base to the tip of your lashes to create maximum volume, length and lift.

3. Finally, flip your grip to hold the wand vertically and stroke upwards to curl and separate each lash.

4. For ultra-voluminous lashes apply a second coat – or as many as you like!

Before and After

My Opinion?

They're Real is the UK's No1 Best Selling Mascara and is hugely Popular amongst Beauty Lovers everywhere! It's very long wearing, intensely black but isn't always the easiest to get off. The Wand is very easy to work with and you don't need to apply many layers to get an intense look. It's also completely smudge-proof. This mascara gives maximum results with minimal effort.

Roller Lash!

What is it?

Roller Lash!:

Grabs
Separates
Lifts and Curls

It's a roller for lashes! The eye-opening Roller Lash Mascara grabs, separates, lifts and curls…while the instant curve-setting formula holds for 12 hours!

Curls just wanna have fun! Formulated with conditioning Provitamin B5 and Serin, the mascara delivers ultimate curl and lift while nurturing and nourishing lashes.

Key Mentions:

Easy to Remove
Contains Ingredients known for their lash Conditioning Benefits
Ink Black, Satin Finish
Water-Resistant
Adds Visible Lift

The Wand

Roller Lash has ahas a uniquely shaped shaped, specifically designed and patented "Hook-n-Roll" brush which can grab, seperate and curl your lashes for an amazing flutter.

How to Apply?

1. Gently wiggle the wand from base of lashes to tip.

2. Repeat across your lashline, making sure to catch every lash.

3. For super Curl and Length, apply Roller Lash first to curl & lift your lashes then layer Benefit They're Real Lengthening Mascara on top.

4. Apply a second coat if needed.

Before and After

My Opinion?

I think this is a nice and easy day time mascara. It removes well and I didn't find it flaky throughout the day. With Roller Lash, I also find your less likely to need a Lash Curler first. It definitely gives a good curl and feels lightweight enough that it won't way down or feel heavy on the eye. It gives a nice fluttery, seperating look to the lashes. I also love using this mascara in Brown on the lower lashes.

Availability

Travel Size €15

Full Size €27.50

Travel Size €15

Full Size €27.50

They can be found in the following places:
Cloud10
Boots
Brown Thomas
McCauleys
Meaghers
and many more....

59 Comments

TO VOTE FOR 1 OF NEXT WEEKS TOP 3
HEAD OVER TO
"HAVE YOUR SAY!"

Emily Ryan

4/9/2020 11:02:35 am

I think it's impossible to get they're real off my lashes so I prefer roller lash it's much easier! x

Christine Dunne

4/9/2020 11:07:47 am

If you get the Benefit They're Real Makeup Remover its so handy xx

The Beautified Guide

7/9/2020 09:23:59 am

Good tip Christine, thanks! x

emily ryan

4/9/2020 11:23:30 am

Oh really? I didn't know they had one I usually just use the Nivea eye makeup remover which is great but like id wake up the next morning and i'd be like someone with a black eye, youd think you got it all and theres still some there. Thanks for the suggestion! x

4/9/2020 11:29:40 am

I think coconut oil is great too. I know there was a whole thing about not using it on your face so i dont anymore but a bit on a cotton round in my opinion is very easy to remove eye makeup too xx

7/9/2020 09:23:40 am

I'd definitely reach for Roller Lash too Emily! x

Joanne Caughlan

4/9/2020 11:05:22 am

Got these in a QVC bundle during lock down got three for like 40e or something. I was delighted

7/9/2020 09:24:21 am

I saw that! Such great value! x

Elaine cotter

4/9/2020 11:10:42 am

Love! x

7/9/2020 09:24:36 am

Thanks for reading Elaine! x

Megan O Sullivan

4/9/2020 11:19:23 am

Anyone know if theres a Benefit counter anymore in cork since debenhams closed?

Sinead Crowley

6/9/2020 12:29:51 pm

Following*

7/9/2020 09:25:08 am

Hi Megan, Boots Half Moon St and Brown Thomas x

megan o sullivan

8/9/2020 10:56:40 am

Thanks! Good to know

Claire Morrissey

4/9/2020 12:06:46 pm

They’re mascaras are the bomb 💗

7/9/2020 09:25:23 am

Thanks for reading Claire! x

Jennifer Long

4/9/2020 12:20:50 pm

I use the bad gal mascara didnt know about the roller lash but it sounds nice

7/9/2020 09:25:38 am

I love Roller Lash x

Chloe Burke

5/9/2020 09:03:13 pm

Love the they’re real, deffo deadly to get off but still love it ❤️

7/9/2020 09:25:53 am

Thanks for reading Chloe! x

Ger O Neill

6/9/2020 11:22:24 am

Is the brow powder from then any good? Xx

7/9/2020 09:26:18 am

Hi Ger, Yes! I Have a Review under this one about it! x

Lucie Warren

6/9/2020 12:27:54 pm

Has the benefit brow bar reopended? xxx

7/9/2020 09:26:29 am

Hi Lucie, I believe so! x

Scarlett Kenny

6/9/2020 12:29:56 pm

Love the roller lash, ive very straight pokey lashes and it lifts them without weighing heavy on them

7/9/2020 09:26:40 am

Glad you like it! x

Victoria Cunningham

6/9/2020 12:30:01 pm

Been using the bad gal one for about 6 months, really like it

7/9/2020 09:26:57 am

Glad you like it Victoria x

bella walsh

6/9/2020 12:30:06 pm

I ordered the theyre real yesterday got it on offer!

7/9/2020 09:27:08 am

That's great Bella! x

layla o connor

6/9/2020 12:30:11 pm

are there stick foundations nice?

7/9/2020 09:27:21 am

I haven't tried them yet! x

aine byrne

6/9/2020 12:30:16 pm

Ill miss debenhams for this :(

7/9/2020 09:27:38 am

Hi Aine, try boots and Brown Thomas too! x

savannah o brien

6/9/2020 12:30:21 pm

Never tried them before, i like the sound of the roller one

7/9/2020 09:27:51 am

Thanks for reading! x

alyson mcmahon

6/9/2020 12:30:26 pm

I use Roller Lash and the Roller Liqud Liner, Have to have my cat eye everyday! xxxx

7/9/2020 09:28:09 am

Hi Alyson, great combo! x

grace robinson

6/9/2020 12:30:31 pm

Can you advise on a good lash curler please jess?

7/9/2020 09:28:47 am

Hi Grace, you'll find a run down under the "Tools and Accessories" section x

emer martin

6/9/2020 12:30:36 pm

Got the three on qvc too like the lady above, fantastic value

7/9/2020 09:28:58 am

That was a great offer! x

zoe kelly

6/9/2020 12:30:41 pm

Shamefully i dont have much from benefit. I've heard good reviews tho :) x

7/9/2020 09:29:17 am

I'd start with their brow stuff - amazing! x

Sarah Daly

6/9/2020 12:30:46 pm

Theyre real hands down the best!

7/9/2020 09:29:34 am

Thanks for reading Sarah! x

charlotte moore

6/9/2020 12:30:51 pm

Does boots stock benefit in store too or is it only online?

7/9/2020 09:29:48 am

Certain stores do! x

8/9/2020 10:57:05 am

thanks

Hazel Smith

6/9/2020 12:30:56 pm

Gorge! xxxx

7/9/2020 09:30:05 am

Thanks for reading Hazel! x

nicola o mahony

6/9/2020 12:39:17 pm

Have you tried the bad gal one? Im tempted to buy the blue

7/9/2020 09:30:31 am

I have only tried the mini version in black, it's good! x

sarah fitzgearld

8/9/2020 11:34:24 am

are any of them water proof

15/9/2020 12:05:09 pm

Hi Sarah, they're water-resistant! x

Hannah O leary

15/9/2020 05:31:36 pm

have you tried/ know if their blue mascara is any good

24/10/2020 12:43:31 pm

Hi Hannah, I haven't tried it! x

Shauna Flynn

25/10/2020 12:00:25 pm

Is water resistant easier to get off than water proof x

11/12/2020 09:57:10 pm

Hi Shauna, sorry for the delayed response, I never saw this comment! Yes it's much easier to get off! x